Source:<b>flac16</b> Set 1: SBD -> PCM Master -> Dat/0 -> Samplitude Professional v8.0 -> FLAC; Set 2: SBD -> PCM Master -> Dat/0 -> Sonic Solutions -> CD -> EAC -> FLAC Transferred by:Charlie Miller Keywords:Live concert
Dancin' In The Streets-> Bird Song, Minglewood Blues, Cumberland Blues, My Brother Esau, Ramble On Rose, Hell In A Bucket Why Don't We Do It In The Road-> China Cat Sunflower-> I Know You Rider-> Playin' In The Band-> Uncle John's Band-> Don't Need Love-> Drums-> China Doll-> Throwing Stones-> Not Fade Away, E: Brokedown Palace, E: Johnny B. Goode
flac16; Set 1: SBD -> PCM Master -> Dat/0 -> Samplitude Professional v8.0 -> FLAC
Set 2: SBD -> PCM Master -> Dat/0 -> Sonic Solutions -> CD -> EAC -> FLAC
August 10, 2012 Subject:
Directed at cccclyde: the cumberland wasnt as good as it should be? Good god man what are you listening to? This show is fantastic, pure dead.
September 21, 2011 Subject:
Bye Bye Sonny
A little googling around, and I believe Bobby's referring to Sonny Heard, one of the GD road crew (at the beginning of Brokedown). I wish I could fill in more info, but I don't know any.
March 6, 2010 Subject:
What a smoker!
I just saw Dark Star Orchestra perform this show last night in Dallas so I went back and listened to the original. Amazingly tight for '84. I'm usually not enthusiastic about mid-80's shows, but this one is very cool! Killer first set with a beautiful Bird Song. It took me a while to warm up to the early Brent period, but he just kills it through this whole show! And Dark Star definitely did it justice, just as they normally do!
June 18, 2009 Subject:
Dancin' at the Greek
This Dancin>Bird Song is one of my absolute favorite one/two openers. Right up there with the 6-11-93 Jack Straw>Foolish Heart(which I attended), and the Half Step-Jack Straw from 11-6-77. The Dancin is pure joy. Brent is sparkling and Jerry is buzzing, my favorite 80s Dancin for sure. (To the guy below who doesn't like Brent; I can see what your saying, Brents originals and some of his synth textures leave alot to be desired. But Brent and Jerry had an undeniable chemistry and when he's on, it's magic. Thats how I feel about all the keyboard players, when they're on, it's pure magic; when they're not, it's rough stuff. That goes for Keith, Brent, Bruce and Vince.) Dancin' drops right into a grate Bird Song with Phil bombs galore, they dont come any finer than this one. The rolling crash cymbals add to the crisp sound of this one-time-only combo. Dont pass this one up folks. A must have in any collection.
The rest of the show is very well played with a smokin' Cumberland. China>Rider and China Doll also shine brightly. Phil and Brent seem to be having fun with the Why Dont We Do It In the Road. "why dont we do it on the drums!" Very solid reading of the classic Playin>Uncle Johns combo.
The only low point for me is Dont Need Love, what that song was doing in the repertoire is a mystery to me. Jerry seems to agree cuz he walked out on this tune a couple times. Oh yeah, Jerry's voice has a little of that nasaly whine that plagues alot of mid-80s shows.
This show has a place in any serious GD collection.
5+ stars for PERFECT SBD!
5+ stars for Dancin>Bird Song.
4 stars for rest of show.
(I give a show 5 stars if I think it is one of the best of that year/era. Trying to compare shows from different eras is impossible, the sounds are so different it's like apples and oranges)
Reviewer:dr. flashback -
February 13, 2009 Subject:
Top Ten for 1984 !!
I think one of the gifts I've received from the years of listening to this music is how the Dead challenge you go beyond the boundaries of your familiar musical taste. No doubt thousands have been turned on to jazz, roots blues, or other genres that they might have shunned if were not for the Grateful Dead's influence.
And "further", within the canon of some 30 years of Dead shows, each period has it's own unique sound and style. Pigpen lovers and fans of 1968 have a hard time embracing the sound of 1990 shows. I too, tended to be a 1968-1974 only listener for many years.
But there's a real thrill awaiting those that dare peek over the fence of their musical backyards - into new uncharted Dead territory.
You discover there are gems waiting to be heard everywhere, like Easter eggs.
Such is the case with 1984, and so especially this show. The last of 3 nights at the magical Greek. And although many would expect me to pick the 7/13 show, with the Dark Star - the playing all throughout this show is really exceptional. Some go as far as calling this one of the best of the 80's period. Hard to argue too much on that. Listen and see!!
A Dancin opener is a nice surprise, and makes me immediately think of 1979, which featured Dancin as an opener many times. One of the reasons why I like this show so much is the somewhat unique song list. Bird Song as #2 ?? Wow.
And nicely jammed it is. Jerry is warmed up already. Minglewood gets things smoking. And Cumberland really shifts to an up tempo mode. The interplay between Jerry and Brent is exciting. Back to Jazz Dead with "Esau". Not my favorite song, but Jerry's leads make it a tasty diversion nonetheless.
Ramble on Rose and Bucket are delivered with conviction, and note that Jerry's voice is in pretty good shape here on Ramble. Just the right amount of rugged. His guitar work on Bucket is scorching - too bad he's a little low in the mix. Some things even Mr. Miller can't fix!
However, by Set Two, Jerry's mix problems seem to have vanished and he comes through loud and clear. Lucky you - his finger-twisting mind-bending noodling here sounds more like 1974 than 1984. Every note is HIT. Ditto his voice. And Phil fans - turn it up. He has a very active role in the post-verse jams in China Cat. Rider is taken at a breakneck pace, at least for the 80's. Has the effect of a strong pot of coffee.
Playin, although shorter than I like (less than 10 min.) really sets up the pinnacle of the show. After the verse, a meditative jam ensues with Garcia painting in short bursts of wah-wah, while Phil, Bobby and Brent create a poly-rhythmic background. This is the band that pulled Dark Star out of oblivion 2 nights before. They gradually bring the ship down to earth, and into the coda of the Playin theme (sans verse) and then Jerry proceeds to artfully juggle the theme into the opening of Uncle John's Band. Beautiful! And I imagine quite a thrill for those in attendance. They nail the vocals. Then proceed to give you a 10 minute version of a magically jammed out UJB that will make you lose time and space. Notes inside of notes, colors inside of sounds. Really shows that the Dead could still pull out a 1974 quality jam when they wanted to.
Space is mostly mellow, with a quiet jam that gets very bendy near the end. China Doll is heart stopping. Jerry really delivers the goods, both vocally and with passionate buzz-saw leads that turn into sweet soaring birds. The rest, as they say, is gravy. Brokedown is almost too much.
A real standout show for this period. And also a superb sounding SBD in a year not usually known for A+ quality audio. Thanks Charlie!!
Check this one out if you're not into 1984 yet. Hope it brings a smile.
Dr. Flashback :-)
Killer Dancin , Birdsong, China Cat-> Rider.
China Doll and Brokedown are spine tinglers.
September 5, 2008 Subject:
Great show even better time was had...
This was the solid show of the '84 Greeks. Dark Star was the highlight of the series but this one was the total show. I was front row Phil's side. Man was it hot! We were baking in more than one way.
Funny how folks who missed the bus view the scene. Oh well, Brent was one of the cogs in the machine, he lent a different feel. I'm glad that when I first entered the scene I met folks from all eras, and they all still dug what was happening, none of the "you missed the only good stuff" types or the "only this stuff is cool" types. I got great history lessons, I learned to appreciate all the styles that make up the GRATEFUL DEAD!
Great sounding recording except Jerry's guitar is a bit in the background when it should be in the very front.
July 15, 2008 Subject:
Brent is the SHIT
Brent was the greatest keyboard player to ever play with the dead period, he knew how to push jerrys buttons and it is sick listening to it,
February 25, 2008 Subject:
Im Confused about Brent!
Just out of curiousity.....I noticed that there are alot of passionate Dead Heads that love Brent. I really can not stand his voice or that Horn style keyboard he was so fond of. Actually I hate most 80's shows just because of him. Does anyone else feel this way?
January 29, 2008 Subject:
Holy Birdsong, Batman!!!
This show is RIPPIN'for two reasons:
1. Absolutely Fantastic Recording
2. The entire band (which is rare) is absolutely on fire!!! Brent and Jerry noodling togethere, Phil dropping bombs with the drummers, and bobby being bobby!
i used to have an abridged version on tape with the wrong date, to boot.
this is an excellent, excellent recording and the playing is just plain old hot, hot, hot.
brent is tearing things up and lesh is just thump, thump, thumpin' away.
don't you just love this internet thing? so much stuff at your fingertips. click and jam - i love it!
January 15, 2008 Subject:
Excellent recording. That's what makes this show 5 stars for me. If it's not a stellar recording, it's hard for me to give it five stars. And this one is stellar.
The show is fine too. The Cumberland isn't as great as it good be. The whole first set is a little short. But the China>Rider is fantastic. The China Doll is maybe my favorite version ever, and that's not usually a favorite song of mine.
Fun sounding show. Why don't we do it in the road? You kidding me?
Get this...errr...listen to this one because you probably don't have much '84 stuff that stands on its own two legs. This one does.
7/13-7/15/84 shows are the pinnacle... how about Cumberland on this one? flyin'.. these are the SBDs you need to get acquainted with.. a Dark Star encore is a tough act to follow but nights two and three the guys are in fine form throughout..
November 1, 2007 Subject:
I give this version of birdsong 5 stars, It's f-ing HOTT!!!!
This show NEEDS to be in your collection! A+ sound and a truly spirited performance. This show stands up with any incarnation or era of the band. Question: at the beginning of "Brokedown" after Jerry sings "fare you well my honey" it sounds like Bobby says "bye bye Sonny" Does anyone know what this might refer to?
Reviewer:skb archives -
November 6, 2005 Subject:
Ramble On Rose
I love the way Brent and Phil sound on this version. And yes, the Bird Song is killer!!!
November 6, 2005 Subject:
BIRD SONG BIRD SONG BIRD SONG etc.
Check out the "Bird Song". Fantastic. It goes way out there. Brent shines. The sound is as good as can be for a 1984 SBD. Highly rec'd for the Bird Song.